Sourcing from the Enemy: Horizontal Subcontracting in Highway Procurement
نویسنده
چکیده
This paper empirically considers the effect of horizontal subcontracting on firm bidding strategies in highway construction auctions. In this industry, subcontractors are hired by prime contractors prior to the auction, and the hired subcontractor may also be a competitor in the primary auction. While the practice of horizontal subcontracting may improve productive efficiency, serving as a horizontal subcontractor softens a firm’s bid strategy, since winning the auction may entail losing subcontracting business. To separately identify the effect of horizontal subcontracting on bid strategies from its correlation with firm costs, I use detailed item-level unit prices charged for the same items by the bidder and the firms to which it supplies those items. Each additional competitor supplied by the firm is estimated to increase its bid by 1.4 percent, consistent with horizontal subcontracting softening bid strategies. Despite this, the winning bid is virtually identical between auctions with and without horizontal subcontracting. This result, along with the characteristics of firms chosen as horizontal subcontractors, points toward an efficiency motive for cross-supply rather than an attempt to soften competition. ∗Economics Department, UC Santa Cruz, 401 Engineering 2, Santa Cruz, CA 95064. (email: [email protected]) I wish to thank Ricard Gil, Dan Miller, David Sappington, and seminar participants at UC Santa Cruz, SMU, and the Stanford-Berkeley IO Fest for helpful comments.
منابع مشابه
Specialization, Integration, and Multi-sourcing: A study of Large IT Outsourcing Projects
IT outsourcing has three broad forms: (i) Single-Sourcing, where the client outsources to one primary vendor, (ii) Single-Sourcing with subcontracting , where the primary vendor involves other/secondary vendors in the project, and (iii) Multi-Sourcing, where the client outsources to multiple primary vendors. Using a dataset of large IT outsourcing contracts from the SCD database with 22,031 lar...
متن کاملDynamic auction environment with subcontracting
This article provides evidence on the role of subcontracting in the auction-based procurement setting with private cost variability and capacity constraints. We demonstrate that subcontracting allows bidders to modify their costs realizations in a given auction as well as to control their future costs by reducing backlog accumulation. Restricting access to subcontracting raises procurement cost...
متن کاملDynamic Auction Model with Subcontracting
We study a dynamic procurement environment with capacity constraints where contractors may re-sell part of the work in the subcontracting market. The ability to subcontract is a prevalent feature of many procurement auction markets but its analysis is absent from the literature. We find that this omission has important consequences, since the ability to subcontract has a substantial and nontriv...
متن کاملSuppliers ’ international strategies Svante Andersson School of Business and Engineering , Halmstad University , Halmstad , Sweden
A longitudinal study of the international behaviour of Swedish suppliers is presented. Three different types of supplier are identified: simple suppliers, advanced suppliers, and own product suppliers. Factors influencing the internationalisation of these suppliers are discussed. It is concluded that the firms’ offer and the customers’ buying strategies influence the firms’ international behavi...
متن کاملInsights into the Strategic Sourcing Decision: Understanding Buyer- Supplier Relationships
The wide range of products and services that are being sourced today has made the company’s procurement organization an increasingly important function. The complexities of managing sourcing options is greater than ever making the procurement function critical for overcoming an increasingly global, complex and uncertain sourcing environment. This paper discusses an overview of relevant sourcing...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2011